One of these years they will actually decide not to advertise and sell the new fan club gift until they have them ready to ship and in hand! Crazy idea, I know!
Got my copy a few weeks ago when the VIP shipments went out (and I'm not even a U2.com member).
when are they going to deliver? I think it is really cheeky taking my money so long ago and then nothing... not even an email to tell me what's going on
Got my copy a few weeks ago when the VIP shipments went out (and I'm not even a U2.com member).
Nothing special, just another coffee table book. Don't get yourselves all worked up only to be bitterly disappointed (again).
Sorry.
One of these years they will actually decide not to advertise and sell the new fan club gift until they have them ready to ship and in hand! Crazy idea, I know!
Compared to some others it's not bad at all. Icon (the Madonna fan club) finally sent the 2010 gift out about a month ago.
So you also have the edges picks cd?
No - I've paid extra for all the extra goodies that were supposed to be on offer.Technically your money was for U2.com membership so of course they are going to take the money
No - I've paid extra for all the extra goodies that were supposed to be on offer.
I haven't renewed my subscription for a few years and this was the incentive that made me decide so I paid $85!! And I've heard nothing...they don't even reply to their emails.
This is shoddy treatment by U2.com...
I think the album translated live in a way that the studio tracks just couldn't. "Moment of Surrender" really comes alive, and the audience singalong with "Unknown Caller" is spectacular.
I disagree completely. I think most of the album was flat and unengaging live, and this was the first time this has happened in the history of the band that was always far superior in a live setting.
"Depending on the venue" is a bit of a cop-out. To these ears most of the songs, with the notable exception of the title track, lacked energy and sounded uninspired - on bootlegs and when I've seen them live (a European concert mind you).
So, assuming
Mothers Of The Disappeared
Return Of The Stingray Guitar
Party Girl
Your Blue Room
Scarlet
will not be on Edge's Picks i'll be mixing something like this... to make one ultimate 360 concert...
00 David Bowie - Space Oddity
00 U2 - Soon
01 Breathe (Edge's picks)
02 No Line on The Horizon (U2.com download)
03 Get On Your Boots (Edge's picks)
04 Magnificent (U22)
05 Even Better Than The Real Thing (U2)
06 The Fly (U22)
07 Mysterious Ways (U22)
08 Until The End Of The World (U22)
09 I Still Haven’t Found What I’m looking For (U22)
10 Stay (Faraway, So Close!) (U22)
11 Out Of Control (U22)
12 I Will Follow (Edge's picks)
13 New Year’s Day (Edge's picks)
14 Angel Of Harlem (Edge's picks)
15 Desire (U2.com download)
16 Spanish Eyes (U2.com download)
17 All I Want Is You (U22)
18 Love Rescue Me (U22)
19 One Tree Hill (U22)
20 Beautiful Day (U22)
21 Elevation (U22)
22 Stuck In A Moment You Can't Get Out Of (Edge's picks)
23 Electrical Storm (Edge's picks)
24 Mercy (Wide Awake in Europe)
25 In A Little While (Edge's picks)
26 Unknown Caller (U2.com download)
27 The Unforgettable Fire (U22)
28 Miss Sarajevo (Edge's picks)
29 Zooropa (U22)
30 City Of Blinding Lights (U22)
31 Vertigo (Edge's picks)
32 I'll Go Crazy If I Don't Go Crazy Tonight (Edge's picks)
33 Sunday Bloody Sunday (Edge's picks)
34 MLK (Rose Bowl DVD)
35 Scarlet (U2.com montreal broadcast)
36 Walk On (U22)
37 Pride (Edge's picks)
38 One (U22)
39 Where The Streets Have No Name (U22)
40 Bad (U22)
41 Ultra Violet (Light My Way) (U22)
42 Hold Me, Thrill Me, Kiss Me, Kill Me (Edge's picks)
43 With Or Without You (U22)
44 Moment of Surrender (U22)
45 40 (Edge's picks)
00 Elton John - Rocket Man
Not Bad eh?
I disagree with those saying the NLOTH songs didn't go over well in the live setting. Maybe not all of them "improved", but I thought all of them were transferred into the live versions very well, maybe with the exception of Magnificent which I thought seemed to difficult for Bono to sing properly. I missed the NLOTH tracks during the last legs of the tour, I thought most of them were appreciated by the audience, especially NLOTH and Boots (which had amazing energy). Not sure about Unknown Caller and I personally wasn't a fan of the disco remix of Crazy Tonight (then again, I don't like the album version much, either), but personally, Moment of Surrender was a highlight for me. Breathe wasn't a good opener, but I still think they shouldn't have dropped it alltogether.
Since the album versions of these songs are strong I am not sure whether they were improved or could have been improved, live, but I think they translated quite well. I still don't understand why U2 didn't play Stand Up Comedy. It may be a dumb song, but I have always expected the band to give it a try since it seemed to be made for a live setting.
I still think it was a bad decision to get rid of so many of these songs as the tour moved on, it seemed like a really coward compromise and gave the impression of the band not appreciating their own album or denying it (which, according to many comments, especially from Bono, actually seems to be the case, which is sad).