Jon Seidman
The Fly
What of U2 produced their own album? No Eno, Lanois, Lillywhite, etc... How would it sound?
If U2 produced their own album?
- Thread starter Jon Seidman
- Start date
The friendliest place on the web for anyone that follows U2.
If you have answers, please help by responding to the unanswered posts.
If you have answers, please help by responding to the unanswered posts.
LemonMelon
More 5G Than Man
I'm not sure they would ever finish it.
Chill Mike D
War Child
If U2 produced their own album, it would essentially be Edge producing their album.
the tourist
Blue Crack Addict
- Joined
- Dec 25, 2003
- Messages
- 27,919
I agree with both of these statements. I also think it'd be a bad idea.
The John Tree
War Child
*brain explodes*
Edge did a lot of production on Zooropa, I think. I think much of the problem might stem from Bono's lack of musicality. Unlike Thom Yorke or Robert Smith who do so much, Bono is less creative, I think. Edge has to do so much already. Still, I think it's possible, but I really don't know.
True.
OP
OP
Jon Seidman
The Fly
But what would it sound like? Would be a basic, clean sound? Punkier? Acoustic? Electronic? What role does the Edge play in deciding the musical direction of every album? What do you think?
As an aside, I think their best song and best sound in recent years was "Window in the Skies". Why didn´t they work more with Rick Rubin I wonder?
As an aside, I think their best song and best sound in recent years was "Window in the Skies". Why didn´t they work more with Rick Rubin I wonder?
Aygo
Rock n' Roll Doggie
U2 has few songs (b-sides, unreleased) that they have produced - the covers from the 1989 sessions, for instance.
It'd be stipped and clean sound, but there's no garantee that it'd be bad.
It'd be stipped and clean sound, but there's no garantee that it'd be bad.
Vlad n U 2
Blue Crack Addict
- Joined
- Jul 6, 2008
- Messages
- 28,386
I can see it happening in the future. 
BVS
Blue Crack Supplier
May of been true back in the day. I don't think he's a virtuoso by any means but I think he's grown a lot and done a lot to learn more about theory and what not... And I'm not sure what you base the "less creative" bit on...
last unicorn
Blue Crack Addict
I'd say Bono is actually the most creative in the band.
Creativity, on the other hand, doesn't have much to do with production skills.
Creativity, on the other hand, doesn't have much to do with production skills.
Caroni
Rock n' Roll Doggie
nathan1977
Rock n' Roll Doggie
According to Flanagan's book, McGuiness is quoted as saying that under traditional songwriting structures 50% of a song's royalty is lyrics, the other 50% music. Bono writes the lyrics (though that has changed some over the past few years), and "certainly writes at least 25% of the music." So there you go.
I agree that the album would probably be talked to death before it would see the light of day. U2 function as a democracy -- someone has to wear the black hat, and usually that person is the producer...which is why they regularly drive such people batty. (Nellee Hooper, Chris Thomas, even Eno & Lanois on occasion.)
Screwtape2
Blue Crack Addict
It'd be very uninspired. The band needs to sort of be lead in different directions by a producer. It is those little 'experiments' that often make up the best moments of the album. Without a producer they wouldn't know what to do with all these peices. I also agree it would never get finished because the band needs to be convinced of the quality of their material.
Rob33
Rock n' Roll Doggie
what on earth are you talking about...what do you mean "Bono is less creative" ??? First of all, that has almost nothing to do with U2 producing their own album, which is the topic of the thread. And, contrary to what you think, Bono probably adds as much if not more to any given song than Edge does during the song writing process...But that's just looking at things logically...this is really only an assumption on my part as nobody outside the U2 camp knows. Seriously though, you don't know shit about "Bono's lack of musicality"...have you been in the studio with them for the past 3 years? You have absolutely no idea, sorry.
The John Tree
War Child
I think, ironically, that if U2 produced an album themselves, it would come out sounding a lot more like their influences and a lot less like U2.
kingofsorrow
Refugee
what on earth are you talking about...what do you mean "Bono is less creative" ??? First of all, that has almost nothing to do with U2 producing their own album, which is the topic of the thread. And, contrary to what you think, Bono probably adds as much if not more to any given song than Edge does during the song writing process...But that's just looking at things logically...this is really only an assumption on my part as nobody outside the U2 camp knows. Seriously though, you don't know shit about "Bono's lack of musicality"...have you been in the studio with them for the past 3 years? You have absolutely no idea, sorry.
1st: there is no need to be a dick when an opposing view is presented
2nd: learn how to understand what you read. he posted "Unlike Thom Yorke or Robert Smith who do so much, Bono is less creative"
it was a comparative comment based on we do know about these 3 artists'.
major_panic
Rock n' Roll Doggie ALL ACCESS
1st: Unfortunately, that's probably impossible for some (most) of the more rabid fans here
2nd: You have a good point there.
3rd: If U2 did produce their own album, it'd probably never get finished, no. Especially if they did it in this decade.
gvox
Ghost of Love
I don't think there is any merit to Mudfeld comparing Bono to Robert Smith or Thom Yorke in terms of who creates what, I think it was a flawed premise to base an assertion that it would be Bono's fault that a U2 produced album wouldn't work. Robert Smith doesn't have The Edge writing with him either, so what? It's apples to oranges.
Screwtape2
Blue Crack Addict
Actually there are tons of artists that successfully produced their own albums. The thing though is that in a lot of cases they slowly learned the craft of production by co-producing an album first. Even when producing, most rely heavily on the engineers.
Marien
Refugee
Have you ever thought about documenting yourself before doing such a comment?
Similar threads
