This thread has been a fabulous read
and I concur with those who applaud the lovetown renditions of LRM - it was truly fabulous to hear live and a marked improvement on the relatively dodgy album version . . .lyrically I think its gorgeous.
WLCTT gets the old skip from me I'm afraid . . . but I think the bono / band bashing over the R&H era is a little unkind.
I actually really like that they gave something they had long admired their own spin despite the fact that they really were putting their heads on the chopping block in the eyes of the critical music media . . . they've always been a band that has revelled in their fandom, revelled in their belief of themselves as musical novices and in the case of R&H I think that this fandom and their attempts to honour it were just wildly misconstrued.
R&H standouts . . . All I Want Is You, Hawkmoon and Heartland